Diet Wars

Diet Wars: Which Side Does the Research Back?

Keto, paleo, carnivore, Atkins, fasting, Mediterranean, plant-based. Every camp says its diet is the answer. Picking the wrong side can cost you years of pain, an early heart attack or both. Here is what the biggest studies actually show, with the numbers.

25 yearsA study of 15,428 adults followed for 25 years found the lowest risk of death in people who got about half their calories from carbohydrates.
18% higher vs. 18% lowerLow-carb eaters who replaced carbs with animal fat and protein had an 18% higher risk of death. Those who replaced them with plant fat and protein had an 18% lower risk.

I'm not a doctor. Everything on this page links to the study it comes from, so you can check it yourself.

Two Generations, the Same Food, Very Different Outcomes

I loved my grandmother with all my heart. She was a wonderful woman. I only wish I had known then what I know today.

My Grandparents

On the plate: The same foods, including bacon and eggs.

My grandmotherShe lived to 97. For about the last 15 years of her life, arthritis and pain took so much from her that she told me several times she wished she just wouldn't get up.

My grandfather, her husbandHis heart could not take it. He died of heart disease at 49.

Me and My Ex-Wife

On the plate: Exactly the same foods.

My ex-wifeShe had no heart disease, no dementia and no diabetes.

MeWhen I was 42, my doctor told me my wife would live to 97 and I would be dead in ten years. She almost got it right. I took after my grandfather.

I don't simply want to live as long as my grandmother did. I want to enjoy the years she couldn't.

Pick Your Battle

Each section opens its own page, with its own sources.

Whole-Food Plant-Based: Change the Course of Disease

In small trials, heart disease went backward instead of forward. Plus the story that made Dr. Greger a doctor, and how I eat.

Read More

The Scorecard: Seven Diets, Seven Questions

Every diet gets the same seven questions: the claim, the short term, the long term, your arteries, nutrition, the money and head-to-head trials. See which ones hold up.

Read More

Your Genes Matter Less Than You Think

Genes explain well under 10% of how long people live. A lot of what runs in families is the kitchen, not the DNA.

Read More

Dr. Atkins: Follow the Money

The medical examiner's report on the man who launched low-carb listed a history of heart attack, congestive heart failure and high blood pressure. His widow and company blamed a virus. Follow the money.

Read More

Keto: After the First Few Months

Keto takes weight off fast. Then LDL can climb, and in UK Biobank, low-carb, high-fat eaters had 2.18 times the rate of major cardiac events.

Read More

Carnivore

Its biggest study is a self-selected online survey. Average LDL: 172 mg/dL. Fiber: zero.

Read More

Intermittent Fasting

In the trials, it did no better than simply cutting calories. In one, the fasting group lost more lean mass.

Read More

Paleo: Did Anybody Ask the Archaeologists?

We're told to eat like our ancestors. The archaeology shows they ate grains and legumes, and an estimated 104 grams of fiber a day. Where did that come from? Steak?

Read More

Look at the People Who Lived It

Rural Uganda: 1 heart attack in 632 autopsies. St. Louis: 136. And if a meat-heavy diet is harmless, why weren't the Inuit long-lived?

Read More

Fiber: The Nutrient They Leave Out

People who ate the most fiber had 15% to 30% lower death rates. Meat, eggs and dairy have none. Every gram comes from plants.

Read More

Mediterranean: Is It the Olive Oil?

The Mediterranean diet works. But the traditional diet was mostly vegetables, beans, whole grains and fruit. Olive oil is better than butter, but it is not the reason the diet works.

Read More

Check It Yourself

Every number links to the study it comes from. Read the sections that matter to you, then decide for yourself.

Sources for This Page

  1. Seidelmann SB, et al. Dietary carbohydrate intake and mortality. Lancet Public Health, 2018. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30122560/