The Scorecard: Seven Diets, Seven Questions

← Back to Diet Wars

The Scorecard: Seven Questions for Every Diet

Almost any diet takes weight off in the first few months. So we asked every diet the same seven questions. What does it claim? What happens in the short term? What happens over the long term to heart attacks and deaths? What does it do to your arteries? Is it nutritionally complete? Who makes money from it? And how does it do head to head against other diets?

Fast start, rising risk

Keto and Low-Carb

The claimCutting carbs lowers insulin, so your body burns more fat than it would on the same calories from carbs.

Short termWeight comes off fast at first, much of it water. When NIH researchers fed 17 men the same calories on a high-carb diet and then on keto in a metabolic ward, keto did not speed up fat loss. Body fat loss slowed.

Long termNo trial has tested keto for heart attacks or deaths. In UK Biobank, low-carb, high-fat eaters had more than twice the rate of heart attacks, strokes and other major cardiac events over 11.8 years (9.8% vs. 4.3%). That is a link, not proof.

ArteriesIn the same UK Biobank study, LDL cholesterol and ApoB, the particles that carry cholesterol into artery walls, were significantly higher on low-carb, high-fat diets. Those whose LDL reached about 193 mg/dL or more had 6.68 times the rate of major cardiac events of standard-diet eaters with LDL under about 135. See the Keto page.

NutritionCuts out beans, whole grains, most fruit and starchy vegetables, the main sources of fiber.

The moneyVirta Health, a company that sells keto-based diabetes treatment, was co-founded by two of keto's best-known researchers, Dr. Stephen Phinney and Dr. Jeff Volek.

Head to headIn the 609-person DIETFITS trial, healthy low-carb and healthy low-fat ended within 0.7 kg of each other at one year. In an NIH metabolic ward, people ate 689 fewer calories a day on a low-fat plant-based diet than on keto.

The original high-meat low-carb diet

Atkins

The claimThe 1972 book was titled Dr. Atkins' Diet Revolution: The High Calorie Way to Stay Thin Forever.

Short termIt can win early. In a 24-week trial of 120 adults starting at under 20 grams of carbs a day, the low-carb group lost 12.9% of body weight vs. 6.7% on low-fat. That trial was funded by the Robert C. Atkins Foundation.

Long termNo trial has tested Atkins for heart attacks or deaths. In a study of 24,825 Americans, those who ate the fewest carbs had a 32% higher risk of death and a 50% higher risk of heart death. Low-carb diets built on animal foods were linked to an 18% higher risk of death; plant-based versions to 18% lower. These are links, not proof.

ArteriesLDL did not differ significantly in the 24-week Atkins Foundation trial. In the larger UK Biobank study, LDL and ApoB were significantly higher on low-carb, high-fat diets.

NutritionStarts with fewer than 20 grams of carbs a day, which shuts out beans, whole grains and most fruit.

The moneyBesides funding research, the Atkins name was a business: in 2005 his estate still held 16% of the company. See the Atkins page.

Head to headIn a 12-month trial of 311 women, Atkins lost the most weight: 4.7 kg vs. 2.2 kg for Ornish. In another 12-month trial of 160 adults, Atkins lost the least (2.1 kg vs. 3.0 to 3.3 kg for Zone, Weight Watchers and Ornish), and only 53% stayed with it.

Our ancestors ate far more plants

Paleo

The claimThe official Paleo Diet website says to avoid grains, legumes and dairy because "we did not evolve eating these foods."

Short termIn 8 short trials, weight fell 1.68 kg on average, and blood pressure and cholesterol improved.

Long termNo trial has tested paleo for heart attacks or deaths. In population studies, people who ate most like a paleo pattern had a 10% lower risk of death, a link that does not prove cause.

ArteriesLDL cholesterol fell modestly in short trials.

NutritionWomen given meal plans from The Paleo Diet book ate 24.6 grams of fiber a day, about a quarter of the 104 grams estimated for Paleolithic diets.

The money"The Paleo Diet" is a registered trademark. The company Dr. Loren Cordain built around it was sold in 2019 and now runs a paid food certification and brand licensing program.

Head to headIn a 2-year Swedish trial in women with obesity, paleo beat standard Nordic nutrition advice for weight loss at 6 months. By 24 months, the difference was gone.

No long-term evidence

Carnivore

The claimMeat alone is said to be all a person needs. In its largest survey, followers reported better health, and people with diabetes reported using less medication.

Short termOnly self-reports. The 2,029 survey respondents chose themselves, followed the diet a median of 14 months and reported their own results.

Long termNo trial or long-term study exists. The World Health Organization's cancer agency classifies processed meat as a cause of cancer: each 50 grams a day, about one hot dog, raises colorectal cancer risk by about 18%. In 1.97 million adults, every 50 grams of processed meat a day was linked to a 15% higher risk of type 2 diabetes.

ArteriesAverage LDL cholesterol was 172 mg/dL among survey respondents who shared lab results, well into the high range.

NutritionZero fiber. Under 10% of respondents ate vegetables, fruits or grains more than once a month.

The moneyDr. Paul Saladino, author of The Carnivore Code, co-founded Heart & Soil, which sells organ-meat supplements. His own website discloses his financial interest.

Head to headNone. No trial has compared carnivore with any other diet.

Works by cutting calories

Intermittent Fasting

The claimEating within a short daily window, or fasting every other day, helps you lose more weight and improves heart health beyond simply eating less.

Short termIn the 12-week TREAT trial of 116 adults, eating only between noon and 8 p.m. led to 0.94 kg of weight loss vs. 0.68 kg for three regular meals, with no real difference. The fasting group lost more lean mass.

Long termNo trial has tested fasting for heart attacks or deaths. A study first presented at a 2024 American Heart Association meeting, and published in a peer-reviewed journal in 2025, followed 19,831 U.S. adults for about 8 years. Those who ate all their food within less than 8 hours a day had 2.35 times the risk of dying from cardiovascular disease. It relied on two days of food recall, and the authors say it cannot rule out other explanations.

ArteriesIn a 1-year trial, LDL cholesterol rose 11.5 mg/dL on alternate-day fasting compared with daily calorie cutting.

NutritionDepends entirely on what you eat inside the window.

The moneyNone we could document for the trials cited here.

Head to headIn 1-year trials, an 8-hour eating window plus calorie cutting (8.0 vs. 6.3 kg) and alternate-day fasting (6.0% vs. 5.3% of body weight) did no better than simply cutting calories. Alternate-day fasting had the most dropouts: 38%.

Works because it is mostly plants

Mediterranean

The claimEating like Crete in the 1950s, with olive oil as the main fat, protects the heart.

Short termIn a 16-week trial, people lost no weight on the Mediterranean diet, but blood pressure fell 9.3 points.

Long termStrong trial evidence: about 30% fewer heart attacks, strokes and heart deaths in PREDIMED, 14 vs. 44 cardiac deaths and repeat heart attacks in Lyon, and 87 vs. 111 major events in CORDIOPREV.

ArteriesLDL did not change significantly in a head-to-head trial with a vegan diet. One olive oil meal cut artery function by 31% for hours.

NutritionRich in vegetables, beans and whole grains when followed the traditional way. Each tablespoon of oil adds about 120 calories with no fiber.

The moneyPREDIMED's olive oil and nuts were donated by olive oil and nut producers. CORDIOPREV was funded in part by two olive oil foundations.

Head to headAgainst a low-fat vegan diet, the vegan diet won on weight (6 kg vs. 0) and LDL. The Mediterranean diet won on blood pressure. See the Mediterranean page.

The strongest evidence

Whole-Food Plant-Based

The claimDr. Caldwell Esselstyn's book title says it plainly: Prevent and Reverse Heart Disease.

Short termIn the BROAD trial, people eating whole plant foods until they were full lost 11.5 kg (about 25 pounds) at 12 months, with no calorie counting. In a 16-week trial, people lost 6 kg.

Long termIn Dr. Dean Ornish's trial, the usual-care group had more than twice the rate of cardiac events. Among Dr. Esselstyn's patients who stuck with the diet, 0.6% had a major event vs. 62% of those who did not. Adventist vegetarians had a 12% lower risk of death.

ArteriesArtery narrowing improved 7.9% in Ornish's program and worsened 27.7% in usual care. LDL fell 15.3 mg/dL on a low-fat vegan diet. In fairness, Dr. Esselstyn's first patients also took cholesterol-lowering drugs.

NutritionThe highest fiber of any diet here. Vegans need a reliable source of vitamin B12, such as a supplement or fortified foods.

The moneyMedicare covers the Ornish and Pritikin programs as intensive cardiac rehab, so they are paid programs. Dr. Greger says all proceeds from his books go to charity.

Head to headBeat the Mediterranean diet on weight and LDL. In an NIH metabolic ward, people ate 689 fewer calories a day than on keto. See the Whole-Food Plant-Based page.

At a Glance

DietLong-term trials on heart attacks or deathLDL cholesterolFiber
Keto and Low-CarbNoneOften risesLow
AtkinsNoneCan riseLow
PaleoNoneFell modestly in short trialsFar below our ancestors
CarnivoreNoneAverage 172 mg/dL in its largest surveyZero
Intermittent FastingNoneRose on alternate-day fastingDepends on what you eat
MediterraneanYes: fewer heart attacks and strokesLittle change in a head-to-head trialGood
Whole-Food Plant-BasedSmall trials: heart disease reversedFalls the mostHighest

Sources for every entry are listed at the bottom of the page.

Sources

  1. Seidelmann SB, et al. Dietary carbohydrate intake and mortality. Lancet Public Health, 2018. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30122560/
  2. Gardner CD, et al. Effect of low-fat vs low-carbohydrate diet on 12-month weight loss (DIETFITS). JAMA, 2018. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29466592/
  3. Iatan I, et al. Association of a low-carbohydrate high-fat diet with plasma lipid levels and cardiovascular risk (HR 6.68 with LDL of 5.0 mmol/L or higher, full text). JACC: Advances, 2024. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11287001/
  4. Hall KD, et al. Effect of a plant-based, low-fat diet versus an animal-based, ketogenic diet on ad libitum energy intake. Nature Medicine, 2021. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33479499/
  5. Manheimer EW, et al. Paleolithic nutrition for metabolic syndrome: systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Clin Nutr, 2015. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26269362/
  6. Lennerz BS, et al. Behavioral characteristics and self-reported health status among 2029 adults consuming a "carnivore diet." Curr Dev Nutr, 2021. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34934897/
  7. International Agency for Research on Cancer. IARC Monographs evaluate consumption of red meat and processed meat. Press release No. 240, 2015. https://www.iarc.who.int/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/pr240_E.pdf
  8. Liu D, et al. Calorie restriction with or without time-restricted eating in weight loss. NEJM, 2022. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35443107/
  9. Estruch R, et al. Primary prevention of cardiovascular disease with a Mediterranean diet supplemented with extra-virgin olive oil or nuts (PREDIMED). NEJM, 2018. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29897866/
  10. Ornish D, et al. Intensive lifestyle changes for reversal of coronary heart disease. JAMA, 1998. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9863851/
  11. Wright N, et al. The BROAD study: a randomised controlled trial using a whole food plant-based diet. Nutrition & Diabetes, 2017. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28319109/
  12. Esselstyn CB Jr. Updating a 12-year experience with arrest and reversal therapy for coronary heart disease. Am J Cardiol, 1999. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10496449/
  13. Esselstyn CB Jr, et al. A way to reverse CAD? J Fam Pract, 2014. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25198208/
  14. Atkins Nutritionals, Inc. bankruptcy disclosure statement (estate kept 16% fully diluted equity in Atkins Holdings; executives 4%). U.S. SEC filing, 2005. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1343494/000090951805000910/jd10-27_disclosure.txt
  15. Mazidi M, et al. Lower carbohydrate diets and all-cause and cause-specific mortality. Eur Heart J, 2019. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31004146/
  16. Li C, et al. Meat consumption and incident type 2 diabetes: federated meta-analysis of 1.97 million adults (InterConnect). Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol, 2024. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39174161/
  17. Lowe DA, et al. Effects of time-restricted eating on weight loss (TREAT). JAMA Intern Med, 2020. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32986097/
  18. de Lorgeril M, et al. Mediterranean diet and the rate of cardiovascular complications after myocardial infarction: final report of the Lyon Diet Heart Study. Circulation, 1999. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9989963/
  19. Orlich MJ, et al. Vegetarian dietary patterns and mortality in Adventist Health Study 2. JAMA Intern Med, 2013. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23836264/
  20. Eaton SB, Eaton SB 3rd, Konner MJ. Paleolithic nutrition revisited: a twelve-year retrospective. Eur J Clin Nutr, 1997. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9104571/
  21. Genoni A, et al. Ad-libitum Paleolithic vs. Australian Guide to Healthy Eating diets: a 4-week randomised trial. Nutrients, 2016. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27223304/
  22. The Paleo Diet (Dr. Loren Cordain). What to eat on the Paleo Diet ("Avoid dairy, grains, legumes, and processed foods"). https://thepaleodiet.com/what-to-eat-on-the-paleo-diet
  23. Ghaedi E, et al. Effects of a Paleolithic diet on cardiovascular disease risk factors: systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTs. Adv Nutr, 2019. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6628854/
  24. Bahrami M, et al. The Paleolithic diet and chronic disease risk: GRADE-assessed systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr, 2025. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10408398.2025.2576815
  25. Allbaugh LG. Crete: A Case Study of an Underdeveloped Area. Princeton University Press, 1953 (as cited by Kessler, SMEA 2015, and Univ. of Toronto). https://muse.jhu.edu/book/42885
  26. USDA FoodData Central. Oil, olive, salad or cooking (884 kcal/100 g; 1 tbsp = 13.5 g). https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/fdc-app.html#/food-details/171413/nutrients
  27. Delgado-Lista J, et al. Long-term secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease with a Mediterranean diet and a low-fat diet (CORDIOPREV). The Lancet, 2022. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35525255/
  28. Barnard ND, et al. A Mediterranean diet and low-fat vegan diet to improve body weight and cardiometabolic risk factors: a randomized, cross-over trial. J Am Nutr Assoc, 2022 (online 2021). https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33544066/
  29. Vogel RA, Corretti MC, Plotnick GD. The postprandial effect of components of the Mediterranean diet on endothelial function. JACC, 2000. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11079642/
  30. Ornish D, et al. Can lifestyle changes reverse coronary heart disease? The Lifestyle Heart Trial. The Lancet, 1990. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1973470/
  31. Hall KD, et al. Energy expenditure and body composition changes after an isocaloric ketogenic diet in overweight and obese men. Am J Clin Nutr, 2016. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27385608/
  32. Virta Health. Leadership (co-founders Sami Inkinen, Stephen Phinney, Jeff Volek). https://www.virtahealth.com/leadership
  33. Yancy WS Jr, et al. A low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet versus a low-fat diet to treat obesity and hyperlipidemia. Ann Intern Med, 2004. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15148063/
  34. Duke Health. Study: low-carb diet more effective than low-fat diet (funded by an unrestricted grant from the Robert C. Atkins Foundation). May 17, 2004. https://corporate.dukehealth.org/news/study-low-carb-diet-more-effective-low-fat-diet
  35. Atkins RC. Dr. Atkins' Diet Revolution: The High Calorie Way to Stay Thin Forever. D. McKay, 1972. https://archive.org/details/dratkinsdietrevo00atki
  36. Gardner CD, et al. Comparison of the Atkins, Zone, Ornish, and LEARN diets for change in weight (A TO Z). JAMA, 2007. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17341711/
  37. Dansinger ML, et al. Comparison of the Atkins, Ornish, Weight Watchers, and Zone diets for weight loss and heart disease risk reduction. JAMA, 2005. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15632335/
  38. Stomby A, et al. Diet-induced weight loss has chronic tissue-specific effects on glucocorticoid metabolism (2-year paleo vs. Nordic Nutrition Recommendations trial). Int J Obes, 2015. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25349058/
  39. USPTO via Justia. THE PALEO DIET, Reg. No. 3591218, owner The Paleo Diet, LLC. https://trademarks.justia.com/779/76/the-paleo-77976582.html
  40. The Paleo Diet. Press release: change in company ownership (2019); The Paleo Diet reinvents its mission (2023; food certification and brand licensing). https://thepaleodiet.com/the-paleo-diet-reinvents-its-mission/
  41. Paul Saladino MD. Heart & Soil (disclosure: co-founder with a financial interest). https://www.paulsaladinomd.com/products/heart-and-soil
  42. Trepanowski JF, et al. Effect of alternate-day fasting vs daily calorie restriction on weight loss, weight maintenance, and cardioprotection. JAMA Intern Med, 2017. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28459931/
  43. Chen M, et al. Association of eating duration less than 8 h with all-cause, cardiovascular, and cancer mortality. Diabetes Metab Syndr, 2025. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40849219/
  44. American Heart Association newsroom. 8-hour time-restricted eating linked to a 91% higher risk of cardiovascular death (preliminary abstract P192). March 18, 2024. https://newsroom.heart.org/news/8-hour-time-restricted-eating-linked-to-a-91-higher-risk-of-cardiovascular-death
  45. Chen M, Zhong VW. Abstract P192: Association between time-restricted eating and all-cause and cause-specific mortality. Circulation, 2024 (abstract only). https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/circ.149.suppl_1.P192
  46. Estruch R, et al. Effects of a Mediterranean-style diet on cardiovascular risk factors (PREDIMED; food donors listed). Ann Intern Med, 2006. https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/0003-4819-145-1-200607040-00004
  47. CMS. National Coverage Determination: Ornish Program for Reversing Heart Disease (20.31.2); Intensive Cardiac Rehabilitation programs. https://www.cms.gov/medicare/coverage/approved-facilities-trials-registries/cardiac-rehab-programs
  48. NutritionFacts.org. Dr. Greger's interview with Gianna Simone (book proceeds to charity). 2019. https://nutritionfacts.org/video/dr-gregers-interview-with-gianna-simone/
  49. Melina V, Craig W, Levin S. Position of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics: vegetarian diets. J Acad Nutr Diet, 2016. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27886704/

← Back to Diet Wars